Pickem Case Study

Pickem Case Study

From paid-heavy to 100% organic growth

From paid-heavy to 100% organic growth

Flavoured Toothpicks

Flavoured Toothpicks

10

10

10

Creators.

Creators.

Creators.

20M

20M

20M

Views.

Views.

Views.

60

60

60

Days.

Days.

1,000

1,000

1,000

Posts.

Posts.

Posts.

$0.40

$0.40

$0.40

CPM.

CPM.

CPM.

THE PROBLEM:

Pick’em relied heavily on paid social for brand awareness

Meta CPMs averaged around $6 and TikTok CPMs around $4, meaning scale was directly tied to increasing spend. As budgets increased, creative fatigue began limiting efficiency, making it harder to sustain performance.

The Challenge

Drive mass awareness while decreasing paid spend and sustainably beat paid CPM benchmarks at scale.

The most efficient and scalable top-of-funnel brand awareness in the company’s history:

20M+ total views were generated organically at an average $0.40 CPM, 10x cheaper than previous paid benchmarks. Achieving the same level of reach through paid media would have cost significantly more.

What This Proved

Creator-led organic content can function as a true top-of-funnel growth channel. UGC can evolve from a branding experiment into a performance-driven awareness engine, enabling massive reach without scaling paid spend.

Some Videos:

461k views

20k likes

26 comments

189k views

12.4k likes

274 comments

86k views

4.4k likes

30 comments